If Canadian Lenders were Cars: BMO

We’re continuing our lender review series here at Redkey Mortgage, where we’re giving each major lender in Canada an automobile comparison. We’ve already reviewed Scotiabank and Manulife in episodes one and two, but in our third installment, we’re taking a closer look at the Bank of Montreal.

BMO is a Big Five bank, which means they naturally fit into a major automobile manufacturer class. But which one? They don’t quite have the off-road capabilities or niche borrower f lexibility that Scotia and Manulife offer, but they do have their own strengths.

Think the front-wheel-drive version of the Nissan Rogue. The Rogue is comfortable, reliable, offers strong value, and what you see is what you get. Those are the same words that come to mind when I think about the Bank of Montreal.

Founded in 1817 in — I’m sure you guessed it — Montreal, Quebec, BMO is Canada’s oldest bank. They hold roughly 8% of Canada’s mortgage market, about 5.5% less than the next closest Big Five bank.

After leaving the broker space for about 16 years, they returned in January 2024, saying they were ready to rebuild the relationship.

So, what do they do well? First, BMO does have niche lending programs, including enhanced options for medical professionals like physicians and dentists. These programs project future income for residents and new professionals.

Second, they offer cashback promotions that can help with closing costs, moving expenses, or furnishing a home. They aren’t always available, but when they are, they can make a meaningful difference.

Third, their 130-day rate hold. Most lenders offer 120 days, so those extra 10 days can be beneficial in some situations. Unlike TD and Manulife, which have opted to outsource their underwriting on the broker channel, BMO has followed a different model, which should allow them to offer better service and scale more quickly.

Negatives: Like all big banks, you need to watch out for their payout penalty calculations, especially for longer fixed-rate terms. And we’re not a fan of the Smart Fixed Rate mortgage, which can include a sale clause.

But bottom line, BMO is a reliable, affordable, practical SUV that offers solid value in the market. It may not be the flashiest choice or the most specialized, but for many Canadians, it’s a dependable option that delivers exactly what you expect from it.

Video Highlights:

BMO: The Practical SUV of Canadian Mortgage Lenders
An introduction to BMO as a Big Five bank, compared to a front-wheel-drive Nissan Rogue — comfortable, reliable, and straightforward, offering solid value without unnecessary complexity.

Where BMO Fits in the Lender Landscape
A comparison showing how BMO differs from lenders like Scotiabank and Manulife, focusing less on niche flexibility and more on predictability, transparency, and mainstream borrower needs.

A Longstanding Canadian Institution
An overview of BMO’s history as Canada’s oldest bank, founded in 1817 in Montreal, and its role in the Canadian mortgage market with approximately 8% market share.

BMO’s Return to the Broker Channel
Insight into BMO’s return to the broker space in January 2024 after a long absence, with a renewed focus on rebuilding relationships and expanding broker-accessible solutions.

Niche Programs for Medical Professionals
A look at BMO’s specialized mortgage programs for physicians and dentists, including projected income options for residents and new professionals.

Cashback and Rate Hold Advantages
Highlighting BMO’s cashback promotions that can help offset closing costs or moving expenses, along with their extended 130-day rate hold — longer than most competitors.

In-House Underwriting for Better Service
An explanation of how BMO’s decision to keep underwriting in-house (unlike some competitors) may lead to improved service consistency and scalability.

Potential Drawbacks to Watch For
A transparent discussion around payout penalties on longer fixed-rate terms and the Smart Fixed Rate mortgage, which may include restrictive sale clauses.

Bottom Line: A Dependable Choice
A concluding summary positioning BMO as a practical, dependable lender that delivers exactly what many Canadians expect — reliability, clarity, and fair value.

Takeaways

Call Us Now
  • BMO is best suited for borrowers who value predictability, simplicity, and dependable mortgage products.
  • As a Big Five bank, BMO offers stability rather than aggressive niche lending or complex structures.
  • Medical professionals can benefit from BMO’s projected income mortgage programs.
  • Cashback promotions and a 130-day rate hold can provide meaningful advantages in certain situations.
  • In-house underwriting may lead to more consistent service compared to lenders that outsource approvals.
  • Borrowers should be mindful of payout penalties and Smart Fixed Rate sale clauses when choosing longer fixed terms.
  • BMO may not be the most specialized lender, but it offers solid value and reliability for a wide range of Canadian homeowners.
  • Understanding how each lender truly operates helps borrowers make more confident, informed mortgage decisions.
APPLY ONLINE NOW, IT’S EASY AND FAST!